- This case study is filed under:
Elgin Sweeper Keeps Ahead of Indoor Air Quality Curve
Lincoln Electric, Automation Division Posted 09/08/2009
Fume control practices increasingly have become a significant focus in welding shops nationwide as the enforcement date nears for the new, more stringent Occupational Health and Safety Administration (OSHA) regulations.
As of May 31, 2010, shops that weld on stainless steel, alloy steel or hardfacing alloys containing chromium or use chromium-containing surface coatings, platings or consumables, must reduce the permissible exposure of hexavalent chromium to less than 5 micrograms per cubic meter measured as an eight-hour, time-weighted average. This change is prompting welding shops nationwide to re-examine their fume control practices and their overall indoor air quality.
This increased focus on environmental responsibility isn’t new at Elgin Sweeper Co. Despite the fact that new air quality regulations loom on the horizon, the company already had begun making plans to upgrade its fume extraction as an intended step along its environmental path.
As the leading manufacturer of roadway sweeping technology, the Elgin, Ill.-based subsidiary of Federal Signal Corp. prides itself on delivering sustainable, environmentally preferential products by incorporating such sustainable features as alternative fuel, waterless dust control and PM-10 compliance into its street sweeper technology. This “green” philosophy carries over into its manufacturing processes, including its busy welding shop.
“We walk the talk and are environmentally aware in our own location,” said David Strebel, Elgin’s safety manager. “We operate in a heavy welding environment – all of our products involve welded parts so obviously air quality is a big consideration. We’ve always met or exceeded OSHA standards and will continue to do so well before the new regulations take effect.”
In the spirit of staying ahead of the environmental curve, Elgin turned to Lincoln Electric to explore new customized options for fume extraction in the plant’s high-volume chassis welding area. As a result of the welding process, heated particulate matter from the fume layer collects in the air surrounding the work area and may also settle on the floor and work surfaces as it cools.
Elgin officials knew Lincoln offered the newest extraction solutions, including an innovative Push/Pull system that could be designed to meet the plant’s specific air quality needs. The Push/Pull ventilation system prevents the formation of a welding fume layer near the ceiling and rafters. Installed similarly to an HVAC system with a main ventilation unit and ductwork tailored to the needs of a particular workspace, the system assists in general air cleaning from overhead without any intervention on the part of welders working in the area.
Push/Pull systems create a cleaner work environment when used in conjunction with localized ventilation or breathing zone protection systems, especially in areas where capturing particulate at the source is difficult. They also work well in welding and metalworking environments for out-of-position and large-piece metal fabrication.
“The system’s intricate engineering makes it an effective choice for high-volume welding fume extraction as it removes the ambient airborne particulate,” said Tim Rosiek, application engineer at Lincoln Electric. “While the operational theory of such a system isn’t new, the way the system is designed and the ducting is routed is innovative in the welding industry. Elgin’s system is one of the first installations of this kind in the United States.”
Maintaining Indoor Air Quality
Elgin welders fabricate many of the company’s sweeping products from the frame all the way through to the final touches, Strebel says. The welding areas include a high-volume chassis fabrication area in the plant’s northeast sector and a busy robotic area in the southeast corner. The robotic area features Lincoln’s Power Wave® 455M power sources, R30iA controllers, Power Feed™ 10MR and FANUC® ARC Mate® M120iB/10L robotic arms. The standard fume hood used in that area features a Lincoln Electric Statiflex®® 6000-MS filter unit.
MIG welding on hot rolled steel accounts for about 98 percent of work performed in the welding shop on such parts as sweeper chassis, hoppers and general assembly. Welders do a small amount of TIG welding for specialized applications. Lincoln’s SuperArc® L-56 MIG (GMAW) welding wire is used for robotic welding, while Weldmark® MIG wire is used for general welding applications throughout the fabrication plant.
Because of its strong environmental commitment, coupled with its heavy welding environment, Elgin wanted to ensure levels remained well above pending air quality regulations and charged its safety committee with choosing an effective fume extraction solution for its heavy-traffic chassis fabrication area.
The committee quickly learned that selecting the best fume extraction system isn’t always a simple task. Numerous factors come into play, as no two shop floors, or even welding areas and materials within the same shop, are the same.
Lincoln representatives walked the safety team through a product selection process to help them choose the best equipment for eliminating particulates from the plant’s welding-intensive environment.
Many solutions can be used to provide welding fume control to protect workers from being overexposed. These include substitution, isolation, ventilation, work practices and personal protective equipment. However, even with the successful implementation of one control method, there are times when it’s necessary to use a second method to further reduce particulates in the overall plant environment. Such instances may include work on large weldments, such as sweeper chassis.
With Lincoln’s guidance, the committee tried a variety of solutions and determined they needed a system that was both automatic and effective. Lincoln representatives suggested installing the new Push/Pull system, as its design and function appeared to most closely meet Elgin’s needs.
“The Push/Pull system’s design is extremely effective and efficient in removing ambient welding fume particulate suspended in the work area where the system is installed. The system also keeps wandering particulate from drifting to adjacent work areas. It’s located well above the workspace and does not interfere with any welding process, including crane activity,” Rosiek said.
The fact that the system remained out of the workspace, yet still effectively cleaned the air, was the key selling point to Elgin officials, said Andy Divin, Elgin’s Lincoln technical representative.
How it Works
Lincoln Electric worked with Elgin to design a custom system by evaluating an in-depth inventory of the facility’s layout and operation. This inventory looked at such factors as application and manufacturing processes, operator procedures, existing ventilation and air movements, overall volume, obstructions and general workshop construction.
“Although the components of the system are standard, it’s the design and engineering of the system that are unique to each facility,” Rosiek said. “There’s no such thing as ‘plug and play’ when it comes to Push/Pull design.”
A typical Push/Pull system features four key elements that are tailored to each customer’s air cleaning needs:
- Extraction – Ducts featuring airflow grids are designed according to the needs of each specific operation in order to move and extract the particulate layer in an efficient, controlled direction.
- Filtration – As particulate moves through the extraction duct, it collects on the self-cleaning filter. When filter pressure reaches a set point, the internal, pneumatic, self-cleaning mechanism begins to clean the filter, dropping collected particulate into an easy-to-empty collection container.
- Fan – A downstream-positioned fan unit, specifically sized for the system and powered by customizable, programmable controls, provides continuous extraction, filtration and re-circulation. To significantly reduce noise levels, the fan is mounted in a sound-absorbing box.
- Re-circulation – Once particulate has been filtered from the air, the air can be re-circulated to push the particulate layer toward the extraction duct. To effectively control the direction of re-circulated air, a re-circulation duct with volume-regulated airflow grids is designed according to specific operating needs and facility layout.
The low-maintenance Push/Pull system requires no operator intervention and only minimal attention from the maintenance technicians. Typical maintenance includes cleaning the particulate collection container and periodically replacing the filter cartridge. A pressure meter measures the filter condition and saturation level in regards to collected particulate matter, indicating when the filter needs to be changed.
Elgin’s system began operating in late January and immediately began clearing the air in the chassis work area. After 60 days, the safety team checked the filter collection container and removed roughly 5 gallons of particulate.
“We estimate our system, based on our first emptying of the collection container, will remove 60 gallons of particulate from the air each year,” Strebel said.
This cleaner environment has boosted employee morale and productivity, said Strebel, who credits some of recommendation to the welders on the safety committee.
“We truly believe in employee involvement in safety because they’re the ones out there on the floor. Their opinion matters,” he said. “People feel better about the work environment and are performing better now that the area is cleaner.”
Users and employers have the sole responsibility for and control over workplace conditions, including the manner in which work is performed and the safety measures taken. Always read and follow applicable OSHA regulations as well as all information on product labeling and material safety datasheets (MSDS available at http://www.lincolnelectric.com/products/msds/ ) when using Lincoln Electric products. Further information regarding their safe use may be found on the following website: http://www.lincolnelectric.com/community/safety/
The operation of welding fume control equipment is affected by various factors including proper use and positioning of such equipment, maintenance of the equipment and the specific welding procedure and application involved. Users and employers should have an industrial hygienist check worker exposure levels to be certain that they are within applicable OSHA PEL and ACGIH TLV limits.