Robotics Case Studies
- This case study is filed under:
Universal Robots Racks Up the Benefits at Eatelex
Universal Robots A/S Posted 12/12/2016
Installing a Universal Robot to pick metal parts out of a press brake solved several automation headaches at Etalex; a Canadian manufacturer of shelving systems that had no room for safety guarding in front of the press and needed a flexible user-friendly robot that could safely handle the pick and place tasks in a high traffic area. The UR10 robot was up for the challenge.
When entering the vast 300,000 square foot production hall at Etalex, your first encounter is Universal Robots’ UR10 diligently unloading metal parts of various shapes and sizes into a large press brake. After the press punches holes in the parts, the robot arm's pneumatic suction cups pick the piece back up and stack them in a patterned pile on a cart. As this happens, employees pass back and forth in front of the robot in the busy hall.
Compared to the other 25 robots in operation at Etalex, all placed behind sturdy safety fencing, the Universal Robots application is an unusual sight. The UR robot belongs to a new breed of robots dubbed “collaborative robots” as the built-in force control limits the force at contact and does not cause bodily harm, enabling them to work right alongside employees. Unlike more traditional industrial robots that normally stay bolted down in one spot, the lightweight UR robots can also quickly be moved and reprogrammed for various production tasks.
Frees up 7 man hours per day
Plant Engineer with Etalex, Jean Francois Rousseau, was eager to try out this new type of robot:
“We needed a flexible automation solution that could be used for 10 different production cycles. Since I only have 6 feet of space in front of the brake press, it was important that I could run this application without safety caging around it.”
Before the arrival of Etalex’ new robot colleague, an employee would manually unload the press brake 8 hours a day. The manual tasks have now been reduced to an hour daily spent on inspecting the quality of each pallet and changing the coils, resulting in an estimated ROI of about 12 months.
The safe choice
Machine operator at Etalex, Richard Clive, stresses how the UR10 has made the work place “a 100% safer”:
“Before, you had to put your hands close to the brake press. There’s always a chance of an accident happening at any time. But with the Universal Robots, there is no chance of anyone getting injured.”
Prior to installing the UR10, Etalex got the approval from the Commission de la santé et de la sécurité du travail du Québec (CSST) (Occupational Health and Safety Commission), which approved the use of collaborative robots at the factory.
Even though the risk assessment deemed the robot able to run without safety guarding, Jean-Francois Rousseau decided to install a zone sensor that causes the robot to slow down once an unknown object enters its work space:
“This wasn’t strictly necessary but having the robot slow down to 20% is reassuring for employees just getting used to work with robots unguarded.”
Learning by doing
Differentiating the UR robot from its caged peers is also the ease of use. Programming happens on an intuitive touch screen tablet where the user simply presses arrow keys to make the robot move to desired positions. Another option is to put the robot in “teach mode”, a feature that programmer at Etalex, Alex Pichette, has used extensively:
“The teach mode allows you to simply grab the robot arm and show it what moves to perform. Instead of having to go back to a keyboard and enter new data, all programming happens right there on the floor next to the robot. That has saved us a lot of time.”
40% increase in sales
Savings is key at Etalex where Director of Operations, Jean Piuze explains that 60% of the company’s cost is the purchase of steel for the metal racks.
“That means that we have to optimize our production significantly to stay competitive and reduce costs. Automating with robots is the only way we can do this,” says Piuze.
“As a result, we’ve had a 40% increase in sales which also means that we did not need to lay people off because of automation. They have now been freed up to perform more challenging tasks than simple pick and place routines.”
UR wherever possible
Etalex is currently working on new robotic cells with two additional UR10s in palletizing applications: one for galvanized shelving and the other for reinforcement channels for shelving. Originally, Jean Francois Rousseau did not think the UR robots could handle these tasks:
“It required a fast 3 second cycle, but we figured out a way to create a gripper for the UR robot that can handle 7 parts in the same cycle instead of one – which meant that we could easily allow the cycle time to be 20 seconds. Our preference now is to use the UR robots wherever possible.”
Canadian market acceptance
Since being introduced to the Canadian marketplace in 2013, the UR robots are now used in a wide range of industries throughout the country. Mark Schick, President of Advanced Motion & Controls, Universal Robots’ distributor in Canada, gives an overview:
“2013 wasn’t just a debut for Universal Robot, but also a market introduction for Collaborative Class Robots. Within 10 months, we’ve sold Universal Robots into Quebec, Ontario, Manitoba and Alberta and serviced inquiries in Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and British Columbia,” says the UR distributor that now has over 20 site installations at varying stages of completion.
“Of significance has been the acceptance of low-to-no safety guarding by safety engineering professionals, ministry inspectors and plant management associates alike. Across the board, UR’s elegant construction coupled with the integrated safety stop feature have gained acceptance to date.”
Applications have ranged from simple machine tending, arm actuators for UGV (unmanned guided vehicle), basic and complex automation/material handling on production lines as well as numerous lab applications and traction within the medical device marketplace.
“End-Users clearly appreciate the advantages of a robust, easy-to-use, safety-certified solution that arrives ready to set-up and run out-of-the box”, says Schick.
Founded in 1966 in Montreal, Canada, Etalex manufactures commercial interiors, specializing in metal fixtures, shelving, wood furnishings and heavy-duty racking systems. The company has 120 employees and used to focus on the Quebec market. With robot automation resulting in increased competitiveness and a 40% rise in sales last year, the company is now ready to compete in the New York and Ontario markets as well.
Universal Robots pioneered collaborative robotics and remains a market leader and first mover within this emerging technology. The product portfolio includes the collaborative UR3, UR5 and UR10 robot arms named after their payloads in kilos. Since the first UR robot entered the market in 2008, the company has seen substantial growth with the user-friendly cobots now being sold in more than 50 countries worldwide. Average payback period for UR robots is the fastest in the industry with only 195 days. The company is headquartered in Odense, Denmark, where all development and production is carried out. Regional offices in North America are in Long Island, NY, Dallas, TX, Ann Arbor, MI, and Irvine, CA